The state of dense linear algebra in Sage

Standard

Finite Rings

Base Ring

Libraries

Overview

Known Limitations

Tickets

\mathbb{F}_2

M4RI

Sage has the fastest known implementation. Matrix-matrix multiplication is either as fast as Magma 2.17 or slightly faster. Gaussian elimination is faster than Magma 2.17.

Some functions might fall back to their generic implementations because M4RI either does not implement it or its implementation is not wrapped

\mathbb{F}_{2^e} for 2 \leq e \leq 10

M4RIE

Sage has by far the fastest known implementation.

Many functions might fall back to their generic implementations because M4RIE either does not implement it or its implementation is not wrapped. Sage uses M4RIE's mzed_t but using mzd_slice_t would be slightly faster and save memory.

\mathbb{Z}_p, 2<p very small

LinBox, custom code

Sage achieves decent performance, but Magma 2.17 is faster for small values. Also, (experimental) specialised implementations exist which beat both by a large margin.

\mathbb{Z}_p, p<2^{22}

LinBox

Sage achieves decent performance on par with Magma 2.17. Performance differences likely come down to the BLAS used in both systems.

Some functions fall back to their generic implementations because LinBox either does not implement it, or the implementation was not wrapped yet. Also, echelonize uses way too much memory because it copies the matrix being worked on due to a function missing in LinBox.

\mathbb{F}_{p^k}

Generic

Very poor performance

Infinite Rings

\mathbb{Q}

LinBox,Pari,IML

Decent

\mathbb{Z}

LinBox,Pari,IML,NTL,Sage

Decent. Fastest known Hermite Normal Form.

\mathbb{R}

NumPy

\mathbb{C}

NumPy

\mathbb{Q}(\zeta_n)

special code

Optimized multi-modular algorithms for arithmetic, charpoly, echelon form over cyclotomic fields.

\mathbb{K}[x]

Generic

Provided by Optional Packages

Base Ring

Libraries

Overview

Known Limitations

Tickets

\mathbb{F}_{p^k}, p^k<255

MeatAxe fork

The fork adds Winograd-Strassen multiplication to the original MeatAxe. The computation of echelon forms is not asymptotically fast, but is faster than the generic implementation in Sage.

Patch needs review

#12103